 |
| |
WEEKLY
SECTIONS |
 |
 |
 |
|
| Think tank warns US against intervention |
|
|
|
Monday, July 21, 2008
By Umar Cheema
WASHINGTON: A US think tank has warned Washington against planning an invasion of Pakistan’s tribal areas, fearing such an action would invoke resistance from the Pakistan Army and 165 million people, who would perceive it as an attack on their national sovereignty. “As a consequence, US threats to unleash the military in Pakistan’s tribal areas ... lack credibility and will accomplish little other than to confirm Pakistan’s suspicion about US intentions.”
It has also urged Washington to avoid criticising negotiations with militants. These should not be entirely written off because a ceasefire can offer a timely breather for Pakistan’s overstretched Army and other security forces. But Washington should certainly demand explanation (or negotiations) about precisely how specific settlements are likely to benefit the counterinsurgents more than the insurgents, it said.
The Council on Foreign Relations’ report titled “Securing Pakistan’s Tribal Belt” states the unilateral US intervention in Pakistan is not a serious option in any case. The US military would find Pakistan’s tribal areas extremely tough going and the primary challenge would come not from the militants or terrorists but from the overwhelming majority of Pakistani people.
Daniel Markey, former State Department policy planning member and expert on South Asia at the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR) has authored the report. “Washington should clarify its specific preferences for future agreements, including a set of general principles (such as accords should include a transparent mechanism for assessing infractions, action timelines should be announced publicly, tribal signatories must put up real property as collateral etc).
The most successful US-Pakistan partnership cannot fix the tribal areas overnight, the report said. This is truly a generational challenge and it must be recognised from the outset. Both Pakistani and American expectations should be appropriately calibrated and institutional investments should be made to reflect the long-term commitment that will be required.
Washington’s close association with the recent military regime has convinced many Pakistanis that the US prefers pliant generals over fractious civilians, the report said. The next administration should counter these false perceptions by demonstrating a higher than normal degree of patience and generosity towards civilian leaders.
In its recommendations, the report states that Pakistan and the United States should establish a joint Security Coordination Committee and a working level cell based in Islamabad and staffed by military and intelligence officers would support the joint Security Coordination Committee with intelligence sharing, strategies for crisis management and long-range planning.
Pakistan’s extremists demonstrate a remarkable capacity to exploit the print and electronic media, undermining public faith in the government and security forces and building sympathy for anti-state causes. The Pakistan government, the report said, has so far missed opportunities to influence the message. The military’s approach to public relations has proven counterproductive in recent years because Army spokesmen are typically unwilling to admit the deficiencies of their own institution, they tend to raise false expectations that ultimately leave Pakistanis (and international observers) frustrated and confused, the report said.
Drawing upon its strategic communication experience in Iraq and Afghanistan, the report recommended that the US military should send advisers to the Pakistani security forces, including the Army and FC, besides offering to share relevant technical expertise in targeted FM radio broadcast jamming.
By many accounts, the popular appeal of Shariah is driven in large part by the breakdown of the provincial judicial process that is notorious for extreme case backlogs. There is a need for quick-hitting reforms of the existing legal structure to grant speedy justice, the report said. For political normalisation and integration in Fata, the report said, the Political Parties Act should be extended to the tribal areas and the FCR be amended to allow limited judicial appeal to decisions by political agents. Delivering resources to tribal leaders in the form of cash or small development projects like schools, wells, or a visiting health clinic might help them compete for public support against a new generation of militants.
The United States and other international partners should include trade routes through Pakistan’s tribal areas as an essential part of the regional development strategy for Afghanistan.
Also, Washington should support (with funding and training) the expansion of a new provincial rapid-reaction force, based on the recent NWFP proposal for 7,500 new officers with a capital cost of $70 million and annual recurring cost of $15 million.
The United States should support the establishment of a Pakistan-Afghanistan peace secretariat with a headquarters and permanent bi-national staff as a means to build upon bilateral meetings and Jirgas.
To address Pakistan’s concern about the US-India relationship, Washington should support and facilitate India-Pakistan normalisation efforts (primarily behind closed doors in New Delhi), the report said. And the US should continue to brief Islamabad at the DCG regarding US-India cooperation in a good faith effort to mitigate apprehensions despite obvious Pakistani perceptions.
|
|
|
| Back
| Send
this story to Friend | Print
Version |
|
|
‘Al-Qaeda, Taliban leaders not in Pakistan’
ISLAMABAD: Strongly reacting to some of the reports of the presence of al-Qaeda and Taliban leadership in Pakistan by the US newspapers and some intelligence agencies, President Asif Ali Zardari on Friday said more |
|
|
Mulla Omar in Karachi, claims WT
WASHINGTON: Mulla Muhammed Omar, the leader of the Afghan Taliban, has fled Quetta and found refuge from the potential US attacks in Karachi with the assistance of Pakistan’s intelligence, the Washington Times more |
|
|
Will PM intervene or will robber barons kill CCP?
By Mehtab Haider
ISLAMABAD: The Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) has warned that it will cease to exist and its actions will become invalid in case the government fails to re-promulgate the Competition Ordinance on or b more |
|
|
Eight militants die in US drone attack
By our correspondent
MIRAMSHAH: Eight militants were killed and two others injured when a US drone hit a house in the Michikhel area in North Waziristan on Friday, the second such attack in less than 24 hours.
Tribal sources sai more |
|
|
19 militants killed in SWA, Khyber, Bajaur clashes
By our correspondents
WANA/BARA/KHAR: Nineteen militants were killed in clashes with security forces in South Waziristan, Khyber and Bajaur tribal regions on Friday.
Tribal and officials sources said five militants were kille more |
|
|
|
Pakistan has nothing to fear from India: Singh
WASHINGTON: Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has said India is ready to resolve all outstanding issues with the country on the condition that it will not allow its territory to be used against its neighbour more |
|
|
|
Qureshi wants result-oriented dialogue with India
MULTAN: Foreign Minister Makhdoom Shah Mehmud Qureshi said on Friday Pakistan wanted meaningful and result-oriented bilateral negotiations with India.
Addressing a press conference at the airport here, h more |
|
|
|
Only 15 pc believe Pakistan is going right
By Gibran Peshimam
KARACHI: Pakistan’s youths are losing confidence in the future and a mere 15 per cent believe that the country is heading in the right direction, while 72 per cent feel economically worse off than a year ago. O more |
|
|
|
Mustafa Jatoi passes away
ISLAMABAD: Former caretaker prime minister Ghulam Mustafa Jatoi breathed his last at the St Marry Hospital in London on Friday after a protracted illness. He was 78.
He leaves behind six sons and three d more |
|
|
|
Slaughter of animals, NRO beneficiaries begins on Eid
By Muhammad Ahmad Noorani
ISLAMABAD: The National Accountability Bureau (NAB) will soon announce its strategy to deal with the cases which are going to reopen on Nov 28, a NAB spokesman told The News on Friday.
“The NAB chairman more |
|
|
|
WFP, Rescue 15 attacks’ mastermind arrested
By Shakeel Anjum
ISLAMABAD: The Capital Police on Friday arrested the mastermind behind the attacks on the UN World Food Programme (WFP) and the Rescue 15 offices in Islamabad.
The terrorist, identified as Jamshed Ahmad more |
|
|
|
Mushahid asks Karzai not to allow use of Afghan land against Pakistan
By our correspondent
ISLAMABAD: Secretary General Pakistan Muslim League-Q Mushahid Hussain Sayed on Friday asked President Hamid Karzai not to allow the use of Afghan land against Pakistan under Indian designs.
“Pakistan wa more |
|
|
|
No Indo-Pak FMs meeting: Nirupama
NEW DELHI: India on Friday said no meeting had been scheduled between foreign ministers of Pakistan and India in Port of Spain later this month on the sidelines of the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting ( more |
|
|
|
US to tighten control of Afghan contracts: Gates
HALIFAX: US Defence Secretary Robert Gates said on Friday that the United States must tighten control of Afghan development contracts as a first step towards stemming rampant corruption.
“The reality is more |
|
|
|
China has stake in Kashmir: Mirwaiz
News Desk
HELD SRINAGAR: As he plans to visit China, Hurriyat Conference leader Mirwaiz Umar Farooq on Friday kicked up a controversy by saying that Beijing has a “direct link” with the Kashmir issue, drawing strong obje more |
|
|
|
Clinton favours Indo-Pak dialogue on Kashmir
WASHINGTON: The United States is encouraging Pakistan and India to resume their dialogue to address Kashmir and other outstanding disputes but any solution must come from the two countries, Secretary of State H more |
|
|
|
Competition Commission forces PIA to fly fair
By our correspondent
ISLAMABAD: Silent prayers of many Hajis have apparently been answered as the Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) has ordered PIA to refund within 60 days the excessive fares charged from the passengers, wh more |
|
|
|
Attack on policemen in Peshawar
By Javed Aziz Khan
PESHAWAR: The death toll in the bomb attack on police party in Yakatoot rose to three after a sub-inspector and another cop succumbed to injuries at the Lady Reading Hospital (LRH) on Friday as the city mourned more |
|
|
|
‘Musharraf funnelling money to improve image’
ISLAMABAD: Former president General (retd) Pervez Musharraf has reportedly funnelled a large amount of money to his former aides in the country in order to improve his image, as he is planning a return to the c more |
|
|
|
Sen Lugar’s wife arrested, charged with drinking, hit-and-run
News Desk
WASHINGTON: The wife of Republican Senator Richard G Lugar was arrested in the suburb of McLean on Wednesday night after crashing into a parked car, and she was charged with drunk driving and hit-and-run, the F more |
|
|
|
briefs...
Bombers kill 23 in Afghanistan
HERAT: Bomb attacks on Friday killed 23 people in Afghanistan, a deadly start to President Hamid Karzai’s second term that underscored spiralling insecurity nine years into more |
|
|
|
ISSN 1563-9479 
