Honest dialogue

The federal government once again resorted to an extremely undemocratic move when it blocked all entry points to the main city of Multan on November 30 before the PDM public gathering. The deployment of heavy contingents of police officers in the city and the arrest of political workers reflected the government’s frustration. The use of unbridled force against political workers inside the stadium reminded me of the military regimes led by Ziaul Haq and Pervez Musharraf. In Multan, both the opposition and the district administration were at daggers drawn and there was a fear of serious clashes between the two parties. However, the threat was averted at the eleventh hour when the government had to abruptly give in, letting the opposition hold a public rally at the Ghanta Ghar Chowk. In a democratic setup, the use of force has no logic as peaceful protests are the constitutional right of every citizen. The PTI staged a sit-in in the federal capital in 2014 for more than a hundred days, but the then government of the PML-N never used violence against the party’s workers.

It is true that public rallies may increase the chances of the spread of the deadly coronavirus. Given the severity of the situation, both the government and the opposition have the collective responsibility to follow SOPs in letter and spirit and postpone such political gatherings. In this regard, the prime responsibility falls more on the government than the opposition. Instead of using force against participants, police officers should ensure that all participants are wearing masks and following physical distancing measures. It will be better for the incumbent government to engage in a productive dialogue with the opposition parties to convince them to postpone the rallies for a few months. The environment for such engagements is to be created exclusively by the government. But if the government’s representatives continue to hurl personal attacks at the opposition leaders, the political opponents will get provoked and may retaliate, which may lead to chaos and turmoil in the country.

Guldar Khan Wazir

Loralai

*****

A democratic system guarantees every citizen the right to assemble and protest against a sitting government. Organising rallies and sit-ins is democratic if the principle of protecting human life and dignity is followed. Otherwise, no one has the right to create a mess and drive the country to the edge of a disaster. Unfortunately, politicians in our country forget the basics and believe that they have a free pass, even if it involves putting the people’s lives at risk. Most of the people in our country are struggling to make their ends meet. All they want and desire is access to the basic needs such as healthcare, education and security. However, our politicians seem oblivious to the people’s needs. The country is in the grip of multifarious crises including the coronavirus pandemic and our politicians are engaged in an ugly war against each other.

Leaders from the government and the opposition play the game of mudslinging and continue to make false promises that they can’t keep to strengthen their support. While the PDM keeps claiming that the government will soon be gone and holding rallies that endanger the life of the people, the government seems to have no other job than to accuse the opposition of all the ills. Surprisingly, in the middle of this chaos, the leader of the opposition in the NA has called for dialogue, which seems to have fallen on deaf ears on both sides. The proposal is sensible and leaders can find out a solution to the situation we are stuck in. Confrontation will not take us far and might end in an outcome that is bad for all the parties. The government and the opposition parties are requested to have dialogue and resolve their issues so that they can help people and stabilise the country.

Raja Shafaatullah

Islamabad