Grave injustice: Not even the dead rest easy in Pakistan’s megacity

In the teeming metropolis of Karachi, Pakistan´s biggest city, graveyards are filling up and the dead are running out of space to rest.

But for the right price, a plot can be ‘found’ for the body of someone’s loved one by shady crews who demolish old graves to make room for new ones. In the coastal megacity of 20 million people, the Pakistan Employees Cooperative Housing Society (PECHS) cemetery has been officially full for five years.

The necropolis is filled. Tombs big and small are slotted like Tetris into every nook -- some pitted deep in the ground, others raised high on petal-strewn plinths. Still, new tombs appear all the time, erected on smashed or scooped-out graves by men charging outsized fees.

AFP witnessed one team hacking at stonework and furtively carrying away baskets of dirt until they had carved out a fresh opening in the cramped earth. "There´s no space in the whole of Karachi — none of the graveyards has space for fresh burials," said digger Khalil Ahmed. "We have to destroy old graves if we want to create new ones."

The government burial fee in this district is 7,900 rupees but two locals reported paying Rs55,000 and Rs175,000 to lay a loved one to rest in the PECHS graveyard last year. Ahmed said the fees are split between 40 men and teens who, when not working, spend their time lolling in the shade.

Gravedigger mafia

Ahmed and his colleagues are part of what politicians and the media call the ‘gravedigger mafia’ — a typically flamboyant term in the parlance of Pakistan social affairs.

Members of the said mafia have been profiting on the changing population dynamic of Pakistan — the world´s fifth most-populous nation with 220 million citizens. It has been estimated that more than four million is added to the country’s population every year.

As the population grows, so does the migration of people from the countryside to the cities, looking for work to escape rural poverty.

Muhammad Aslam has witnessed the gravedigger mafia flourish as Karachi´s population boomed. The 72-year-old said the PECHS graveyard was a ‘deserted place’ when he had moved next door in 1953 but the space shrank fast as burial prices rose for his 14 family members interred over the years. In 1967 Aslam´s family paid 50 rupees to bury his grandfather but a relative buried at the hands of the mafia in 2020 cost Rs33,000.

"The basic issue is that infrastructure is insufficient," said Ali Hassan Sajid, a spokesman for the Karachi Metropolitan Corporation (KMC). The KMC manages 39 of around 250 graveyards citywide, including the PECHS’s. Of them, six are closed, while the rest are almost full. "In some parts of the city, the infrastructure is the same that existed when Pakistan was founded," Sajid admitted. He acknowledged the existence of gravedigger mafias conducting burials at closed sites and claimed that efforts to evict them were under way.

The gangs are also reported to be flourishing in the cities of Rawalpindi, Peshawar and Lahore.

A missing memorial

Whether the gravedigger mafias represent a problem depends on who in being asked. Sajid said families eager to bury relatives alongside previous generations offer high prices that lure gravediggers. Ahmed, a gravedigger, says he provides an essential service in a city unable to administer itself, scratching out a meagre living in return.

While some locals view the practice as part of the faulty fabric of life in a teeming city, it is a source of angst for others.

Muhammad Abdullah Saif´s father was buried in the PECHS graveyard decades ago. Today the faded green tomb is surrounded by empty sacks of cement and the shattered cusps of tombstones.The mafias generally pick untended graves for demolition. "We have to come and visit regularly or the grave will be knocked down," said the 32-year-old.

Muzammil Asif, meanwhile, must clamber over a carpet of ankle-twisting hazards to reach the grave of his teenage sister buried here last summer. "Graves are desecrated when one walks over them," the 21-year-old complains.

In the Korangi graveyard, Muhammad Munir has experienced the saddest loss. Every year, he comes to offer prayers in the cemetry where his father was buried. The place seems to be an amphitheatre of tumbledown tombstones fringed by ragged flags. The grave of Munir’s father is long gone, demolished more than 20 years ago and replaced by another. That replacement is gone too, swapped out for a new one. Now he´s unsure of exactly where his father rests. "It´s painful," he said. "The grave was the last sign of him."