ISLAMABAD: The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has opposed any move for reducing GST on sugar and abolishing withholding tax on import of pulses, arguing that reduction in taxes will only increase profits of influential sugar industry owners.
The incumbent PTI led regime is contemplating upon different options to reduce the price hike and different proposals are under consideration, including slashing down the GST rate on sugar from 17 to 5 percent and abolishing 2 percent Withholding Tax on import of pulses.
“The FBR has opposed reduction in the GST rate from 17 to 5 percent because there is impact of Rs3.25 per kg with increased rate of taxation. So if the government reduces the tax, it will be pocketed by owners of sugar mills and benefit will not reach consumers” a top FBR official confirmed to The News here on Thursday.
On the other hand, the working done by the government showed that the reduction in the GST rate from 17 to 5 percent would bring down the price of sugar by Rs9.72 per kg in the domestic market against the average existing price of Rs80.9 at the moment. It will cause a loss to national exchequer to the tune of Rs21 billion with reduction in the GST rate.
Now the FBR has argued that they were charging GST at factory rate of Rs6 per kg and with increased GST rate, the FBR was collecting Rs3.25 per kg so the impact of price hike because of taxation was limited to this effect only. “We have told the government if the GST rate was reduced, it would go into the pockets of sugar mill owners” said the FBR official.
On the sugar situation, the sugar production stood at 5 million tons and the carryover stock was standing in the range of 537,000 tons, so the net availability of sugar had touched 5.537 million tons against the total consumption requirement of 5.674 million tons. The current price of sweetener was hovering around Rs80.9 per kg against the last year’s price of Rs58.59 per kg, so its prices went up by Rs22 per kg in the domestic market or Rs37.37 percent. Now the government is recommended to incentivize import of 0.3 million tons through removal of all taxes and duties, discourage hoarding through taking stern action and reduction in the GST rate.
The Ministry of National Food Security and Research had proposed abolishing 2 percent Withholding Tax (WHT) on import of pulses. The FBR argued that the charging of tax was causing Rs1.50 per kg hike in prices, so the FBR would be happy if importers agreed to pay tax on their income but if they do not agree, then 2 percent WHT must continue.
