Trending

Paul Anthony Kelly opens up on 'nervousness' of playing JFK Jr.

Paul Anthony Kelly plays JFK Jr. in Ryan Murphy's 'Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette'

February 12, 2026
Paul Anthony Kelly opens up on 'nervousness' of playing JFK Jr.
Paul Anthony Kelly gets candid about nervousness of playing JFK Jr.

Paul Anthony Kelly knows what a big deal it is to portray John F. Kennedy Jr.

Paul plays the beloved figure in Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette portraying the titular beloved figure JFK Jr. alongside Sarah Pidgeon as Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy.

The 37-year-old is "nervous for [the show] to come out."

"For this to be my first big production, playing someone so beloved, I mean, it's definitely not lost on me," Kelly, 37, told People. "I really had to tighten up my bootstraps and do deep dives, learn everything I could."

Paul "knew a little bit about" the real-life couple before getting cast in the Ryan Murphy series, but "definitely, during this whole process, I really got to know them, I think, pretty well. Within reason, of course."

"I'm from Canada, so it's not necessarily our cultural zeitgeist," he explained. "But I was familiar with who they are — or were."

The actor, who’s making his debut with the project, felt "very, very fortunate" that there was such a "wealth of information" available on JFK Jr. so he could prepare well.

"He's a very well-documented individual, so I was able to consistently go back and rely, review, interpret that information," he said.

"The whole experience was like lightning in a bottle," the actor added. "The whole process in making it was an incredible experience. A wonderful cast, wonderful crew, producers, writers — everything."

Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette premieres on FX and Hulu on Feb. 12.