close
Saturday May 17, 2025

Mark Carney, Pierre Poilievre face off in Canada's leadership race

Liberal Party leader never held elected office while Conservative leader moved up political ranks in past 20 years

By AFP
April 21, 2025
This combination of images shows Canadas Liberal Party leader Mark Carney (left) and Conservative Party leader Pierre Poilievre. — Reuters/File
This combination of images shows Canada's Liberal Party leader Mark Carney (left) and Conservative Party leader Pierre Poilievre. — Reuters/File

As Canada prepares for next week's election, the paths of the leading candidates, Liberal Party leader Mark Carney and Conservative Party leader Pierre Poilievre, to the pinnacle of national politics could not be more different.

Carney ascended to the role of prime minister just weeks ago after winning a leadership contest to replace former prime minister Justin Trudeau. Notably, the former central banker has never held elected office before.

In contrast, Conservative Party leader Pierre Poilievre has been a presence in Parliament since 2004, first elected at just 25 years old. Over his two decades in Ottawa, he has honed his debate skills and established himself as a formidable opponent.

The next government will face the challenge of navigating a strained relationship with the United States, particularly under President Donald Trump, who has raised the provocative prospect of Canada becoming a US state.

Dealing with crisis

Carney was born in Fort Smith, a community near the Arctic in Canada's Northwest Territories.

He was raised in the western city of Edmonton and played competitive hockey in his youth.

He studied at Harvard in the United States and Oxford in England, and the initial part of his career saw him make a fortune as an investment banker at Goldman Sachs, working in New York, London, Tokyo and Toronto.

Carney then joined the Canadian civil service, eventually being appointed governor of the Bank of Canada in 2008.

In 2013, then-British Prime Minister David Cameron appointed him to lead the Bank of England, making him the first non-British person to hold the position.

After finishing his term in London, he joined Brookfield, a massive Canadian corporation and served as United Nations advisor promoting pro-climate initiatives in finance.

Rumours had long circulated that Carney was eyeing an entry into Canadian politics. When Trudeau announced his plans to resign on January 6, Carney pounced.

The 60-year-old has argued that his experience at the Bank of Canada through the 2008-2009 financial crisis and with the Bank of England through the turbulence surrounding the 2016 Brexit vote has equipped him to handle Canada's upheaval in US relations.

Carney has described the Trump threat as "the most serious crisis of our lifetime," and said the US president "wants to break us so he can own us."

But the father of four and accomplished marathon runner has also sought to project calm, telling voters he can reposition Canada on the global stage and reduce reliance on the US, a country he said "we can no longer trust."

Dalhousie University professor Lori Turnbull noted Carney "doesn't have a dynamic communication style" but comes across as "a reassuring guy who knows what he's talking about."

'Nothing like Trump'

Poilievre had established himself as a relentless and effective critic of Trudeau, who became deeply unpopular toward the end of decade in power.

The Tory leader has also drawn comparisons to Trump, in part over his attacks on the media and a previous promise to be Canada's "anti-woke prime minister."

But Poilievre has been forced to adjust in response to polling indicating Canadians want a leader who can confront Trump.

"I am nothing at all Like Trump," Poilievre insisted on a Quebec talk show this month, emphasising his "humble beginnings."

At Thursday's election debate, Poilievre used his closing statement to remind voters that he was born to a single mother before being adopted by teachers.

He said his parents "raised him to believe that anyone who worked hard could do anything. That promise feels broken today."

Poilievre has argued he can also resist Trump, while insisting poor Liberal economic management under Trudeau left Canada vulnerable to US hostility.

He has also aimed to soften his tone, but for University of Alberta professor Frederic Boily, the stylistic changes may have come too late.

"To become prime minister, he must project hope and a positive vision, and he's struggled to make that transition," he told AFP.

Poilievre was born in the western city of Calgary and advances policies supported by the region's oil industry, including new pipeline construction.

He also built support nationally as a critic of pandemic lockdown policies that some saw as excessive.

He has been re-elected eight times by his Ottawa area district and served in the cabinet of former Conservative prime minister Stephen Harper.

His wife, Anaida Poilievre, emigrated from Venezuela to Canada. They have two children.