Wednesday October 20, 2021

Inquiry reveals 'massive' child sexual abuse in French Catholic Church

Report findings prompt outrage as Catholic Churches around the world face a growing number of abuse claims and prosecutions

October 05, 2021
Hands of a member of a church raised for worship. Photo — AFP
Hands of a member of a church raised for worship. Photo — AFP

PARIS: Around 216,000 minors were sexually abused by the French Catholic clergy since 1950, said an independent commission Tuesday, terming the misdeed a “massive phenomenon” which was covered up by a “veil of silence”.

The commission’s two-and-a-half-year inquiry and 2,500-page report prompted outrage as the Catholic Church in France and around the world face a growing number of abuse claims and prosecutions.

Pope Francis expressed "great pain" over the "appalling" findings, a Vatican spokesman said, adding: "His thoughts turn first to the victims, with great sorrow for their wounds and gratitude for their courage in speaking out."

The report found that the "vast majority" of victims were pre-adolescent boys from a variety of social backgrounds. Their abusers were mainly priests, bishops, deacons and monks.

When claims against lay members of the Church, such as teachers at Catholic schools are included, the number of child abuse victims climbs to 330,000 since 1950, the report found.

"These figures are more than worrying, they are damning and in no way can remain without a response," commission chief Jean-Marc Sauve told a press conference that unveiled the nearly 2,500-page report.

"Until the early 2000s, the Catholic Church showed a profound and even cruel indifference towards the victims."

Archbishop Eric de Moulins-Beaufort, president of the Bishops´ Conference of France (CEF), which co-requested the report, expressed his "shame and horror" at the findings.

"My wish today is to ask forgiveness from each of you," he told the news conference.

Deviant system

Sauve denounced the "systemic character" of efforts to shield clergy from sex abuse claims and urged the Church to pay reparations even though most cases are well beyond the statute of limitations for prosecution.

His commission detailed 45 recommendations to avoid further abuse, not least a requirement that priests inform prosecutors of any child abuse during the sacrament of confession — under Catholic doctrine priests are usually bound to absolute secrecy.

"We expect clear and concrete responses by the Church," a collective of six victims' associations said.

The report, at nearly 2,500 pages, found that the "vast majority" of victims were pre-adolescent boys from a variety of social backgrounds.

"The Catholic Church is, after the circle of family and friends, the environment that has the highest prevalence of sexual violence," the report said.

Sauve had already told AFP on Sunday that a "minimum estimate" of 2,900 to 3,200 clergy members had sexually abused children in the French Church since 1950.

Yet only a handful of cases prompted disciplinary action under canonical law, let alone criminal prosecution.

The commission began its work after Pope Francis vowed to address abuse by priests in May 2019, ordering people aware of cases to report them to Church officials.

In France in particular, the case of Philippe Barbarin, an archbishop initially convicted of not telling police of a priest's abuse of boy scouts, drew outrage after he was acquitted in January 2020.

Francois Devaux, head of a victims´ association, condemned a "deviant system" and called for a new "Vatican III" council to chart a way forward.


"You have finally given an institutional recognition to victims of all the Church's responsibilities, something that bishops and the pope have not yet been prepared to do," Devaux said at the news conference.

"I´m dumbfounded," said Yolande Ormancey, a 63-year-old parishioner praying Tuesday at the Fourviere basilica in Lyon, southeast France.

"I expect these criminals to be punished, and support offered to victims whose lives have been ruined," she said.

The victim estimates were largely based on a representative study carried out by France's INSERM health and medical research institute.

Sauve and his team of 21 specialists, all unaffiliated with the Church, also interviewed hundreds of people who came forward to tell their stories.

"If the veil of silence covering the acts committed has finally been torn away... we owe it to the courage of these victims," he wrote.

The commission also had access to police files and Church archives, citing only two cases of refusals by Church institutions to turn over requested documents.

Overall, it found that 2.5 per cent of French clergy since 1950 had sexually abused minors, a ratio below the 4.4 to seven per cent uncovered by similar inquiries in other countries.

While that would imply an unusually high number of victims per assailant, "a sexual predator can in fact have a high number of victims, especially those who attack boys," the report found.