UK says no warning shots were fired, says ship is conducting innocent passage through Ukrainian waters
MOSCOW: Russia claimed on Wednesday that it had fired warning shots at a British navy destroyer in the Black Sea over an alleged violation of the country's territorial waters, but the UK denied the incident had occurred.
Incidents involving Western aircraft and ships are not uncommon at Russia's borders, especially during heightened tensions with Washington, Brussels and London, but rarely result in open fire.
The HMS Defender "was given a preliminary warning that weapons would be used if the state borders of the Russian Federation were violated. It did not react to the warning," the Russian defence ministry said, according to Interfax news agency.
The ministry added that "a border patrol ship fired warning shots" and a Su-24 aircraft dropped four bombs along the destroyer's path. It said that the ship then left Russian waters.
But the UK's defence ministry swiftly denied that the incident had happened.
"No warning shots have been fired at HMS Defender. The Royal Navy ship is conducting innocent passage through Ukrainian territorial waters in accordance with international law," the ministry said.
London said it believed Russia was "undertaking a gunnery exercise" and had provided prior warning of its activity.
After announcing that it had fired warning shots at HMS Defender — a T45 destroyer — Russia's defence ministry summoned Britain´s military attache, Interfax reported.
The defence ministry then released a statement denouncing the "dangerous actions" of HMS Defender, describing the incident as a "gross violation of the UN convention" and calling on London to conduct an investigation.
Meanwhile, foreign ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova said that Britain's ambassador to Russia would be summoned over the incident.
"We qualify this as a gross British provocation that runs counter to international law and Russian law," she said.
According to Moscow, the incident took place off the coast of Cape Fiolent on Crimea, which Russia annexed from Ukraine in 2014, also claiming the peninsula's coastal waters.
The Royal Navy said earlier this month that HMS Defender had "peeled away" from its strike group conducting NATO operations in the Mediterranean to carry out "her own set of missions" in the Black Sea.
On Wednesday, UK Defence Secretary Ben Wallace said in a statement that HMS Defender had been carrying out a "routine transit from Odessa towards Georgia across the Black Sea".
Earlier on Wednesday, President Vladimir Putin said Russia was "concerned" about the NATO build-up near Russian borders.
Addressing an international security conference in Moscow, Putin said the alliance "refuses to constructively consider our proposals to de-escalate tensions and reduce the risk of unpredictable incidents".
The US periodically sends warships to the region in a show of support for Ukraine, often drawing protests from Russia.
Ukraine's Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba on Wednesday slammed Russia's "aggressive and provocative policy" in the Black Sea region, describing it on Twitter as a "constant threat" to Kiev and its allies.
At the height of tensions over Ukraine this spring after Russia built up troops on its border and in Crimea, Moscow stepped up military exercises in the Black Sea and Washington warned it would send two warships.
Those ships were never dispatched, as Russia pulled back its forces and the tensions eased.
At the time, Russia also threatened to close parts of the Black Sea, which would have affected access to Ukrainian ports in the Sea of Azov, which is connected to the Black Sea through the Kerch Strait on the eastern tip of Crimea.
Ukraine had been free to navigate the Kerch Strait — of crucial importance to Kiev for exporting grain and steel — along with Russia until 2014, when Moscow claimed full control of the waterway after annexing Crimea.
"By international law, of course, the waters off Crimea are not Russian, as the annexation is not recognised," Mark Galeotti, a professor of Russian studies at University College London, tweeted on Wednesday.
"Continuing to pass those waters — without being too provocative — is a crucial way of reaffirming law over land and sea grab."
The most serious recent tensions over the waters were in November 2018, when Russian forces boarded and took control of three ships as they headed through the Kerch Strait.
Russia captured 24 Ukrainian sailors in the seizure, returning them to Ukraine as part of a prisoner swap in September 2019.