Pakistanis spend winter breathing air pollution 20 times over safe levels

LAHORE: Tens of millions of Pakistanis spent at least four months breathing toxic air pollution 20 times above safe levels, in the worst winter smog season for several years, according to data analysed by AFP.

Pakistan regularly ranks among the world’s most polluted countries, with Lahore often the most polluted megacity between November and February.

AFP’s analysis of data recorded since 2018 by independent air monitoring project AQICN shows the 2024-2025 winter smog season started a month earlier in October and persisted at higher levels, including in cities normally less affected by pollution.

Lahore’s 14 million residents spent six months breathing concentrations of PM2.5 — tiny particles that can penetrate the lungs and bloodstream — at levels 20 times or more than recommended by the World Health Organization. Those in Karachi, Pakistan’s biggest city, and the capital Islamabad were subjected to 120 days of the same choking pollution levels.

Experts say the pollution is primarily caused by factory and traffic emissions. It worsens in winter as farmers burn crop stubble and cooler temperatures and slow-moving winds trap the deadly pollutants.

This year, winter rains that typically bring relief did not arrive until late February, as climate change renders Pakistan’s weather patterns increasingly unpredictable. The smog was so thick it could be seen from space and prompted authorities to close schools serving millions of students across Punjab, including Lahore.

Young climate activist Risha Rashid said Islamabad is fast becoming “another Lahore” and has launched legal action against the government. “It’s really suffocating,” the 21-year-old, who has asthma, told AFP. “I cannot go out, even if I have exams. It’s not just affecting our physical health but our mental health as well.”

An Ipsos poll in November found four out of five Pakistanis said they were affected by the smog. Its effects are worse for children, who breathe more rapidly and have weaker immune systems.

During this smog season, the Punjab government declared a “war on smog”, increasing installation of public air quality monitoring devices tenfold to around 30 and offering farmers subsidised rentals of machinery to clear crop stubble and avoid burning. It also pledged to increasingly enforce emissions regulations on tens of thousands of factories and more than 8,000 brick kilns, a major source of black carbon emissions.

But environmentalists and experts say action has been piecemeal and sometimes counterproductive, including restrictions on private air quality monitoring devices that the government claims give “misleading results that spread panic.” And anti-smog machines, including a tower in Lahore, were shut down two months after installation, are effectively useless, experts say. “It is like putting an air conditioner out in the open,” said one who spoke on condition of anonymity.

Efforts that tackle pollution’s effects, rather than its source, miss the point, said Ahmad Ali Gul at Lahore’s University of Management and Technology. “First, we need to focus on reducing the emissions and then we talk about how to protect ourselves from smog.” Pakistan has limited vehicle emissions standards, and officials admit 83 percent of Lahore’s carbon emissions are from transport. “Switching to a cleaner fuel would give immediate results, we’ve seen it in other countries,” said Frank Hammes, the global CEO of the Switzerland-based AQI air quality project. But that “needs a pretty strong central effort to push down sometimes the painful changes that need to be made in order to reduce air pollution,” he added.

Pakistan’s government wants electric vehicles (EVs) to account for a third of new sales by 2030.

The cheaper Chinese models launched in Pakistan in 2024, currently make up just a fraction of overall car sales, according to the World Bank. Pakistan had a taste of clean air during the pandemic, when a lockdown forced vehicles off the streets and factories to close in March 2020, but it was short-lived as the economic impact was too great for many to bear.