Pakistan’s early exit from the ICC Champions Trophy has left fans heartbroken and raised serious concerns about the team’s planning, selection, and overall management. Defending champions Pakistan, who entered the tournament with high hopes, suffered back-to-back defeats-first to New Zealand and then to arch-rivals India-effectively sealing their fate.

However, New Zealand’s emphatic victory over Bangladesh ultimately confirmed Pakistan’s elimination, marking an unceremonious end to their campaign in a major ICC event hosted on home soil for the first time since the 1996 World Cup.

The disappointment is immense for a cricket-loving nation where the sport is more than just a game-it is a unifying force. The rich history of Pakistan cricket, which boasts triumphs such as the 1992 World Cup and the 2017 ICC Champions Trophy, now stands in stark contrast to this latest debacle. However, while the exit is painful, it is not the end of Pakistan cricket. The key lies in learning from these mistakes and moving forward with strategic planning and accountability.

Failure Rooted in Poor Selection and Mismanagement

As the host nation, Pakistan had two critical responsibilities: first, to successfully organize a world-class ICC event, and second, to assemble a competitive squad capable of defending their title. While the first objective was met despite external challenges, the second was a catastrophic failure. The Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB), selection committee, and team management must bear the brunt of the blame for the team’s dismal performance.

One of the most baffling selection decisions was the exclusion of two of Pakistan’s premier spinners, Sajid Khan and Nauman Ali. Despite the clear advantage of quality spin in subcontinental conditions, the selectors overlooked them, a move that proved costly. New Zealand’s spinners demonstrated just how effective slow bowlers can be in these conditions, extracting sharp turn and stifling Pakistan’s batting lineup. In contrast, Pakistan’s spin attack lacked penetration and consistency, failing to build any sustained pressure on opponents.

The omission of experienced spinners wasn’t the only questionable decision. The overall squad selection seemed haphazard, with key positions either filled by out-of-form players or left exposed. Poor tactical choices further compounded the issue, as Pakistan struggled to adapt to match situations, a deficiency that ultimately led to their downfall.

Tactical Blunders and Familiar Weaknesses

Pakistan’s Champions Trophy campaign exposed the same recurring problems that have plagued the team for years-lack of strategic planning, ineffective middle-order batting, and inconsistent bowling. Despite having the advantage of home conditions, Pakistan appeared outplayed, outclassed, and outmaneuvered.

Their match against New Zealand was a glaring example of their shortcomings. The Kiwis posted a daunting 320-run total, thanks to brilliant performances from Will Young and Tom Latham. While Pakistan’s bowlers had moments of brilliance in the middle overs, they faltered at crucial junctures, conceding too many runs in the death overs.

In response, Pakistan’s batting followed an all-too-familiar pattern of failure. The top order lacked intent, with Babar Azam’s sluggish 81-ball fifty and Fakhar Zaman’s struggles preventing Pakistan from building a solid foundation. Instead of seizing the moment, the batters played with excessive caution, allowing New Zealand’s bowlers to dictate terms.

The story repeated itself against India, where Pakistan once again crumbled under pressure. A lack of aggression, poor shot selection, and an inability to handle high-pressure situations proved disastrous. These persistent issues highlight deeper flaws in Pakistan’s approach to modern-day cricket.

A Broken System: The Need for Overhaul

Pakistan’s failure in the Champions Trophy is not just about one bad tournament-it is symptomatic of a much larger problem. Years of weak domestic structures, inconsistent selection policies, and mismanagement have left Pakistan cricket in a precarious state.

For far too long, Pakistan cricket has relied on temporary fixes rather than addressing fundamental issues. The selection process has been riddled with favoritism, and the team’s strategic decisions often appear based on gut feelings rather than proper analysis. The PCB’s leadership has been inconsistent, with frequent changes in selection committees and coaching staff further disrupting the team’s development.

Time for Meaningful Reforms, Not
Cosmetic Fixes

Pakistan must take this failure as a wake-up call and initiate comprehensive reforms to address these longstanding issues. The time for cosmetic changes is over; what Pakistan cricket needs is an overhaul-a shift towards a professional, merit-based system that prioritizes performance over politics.

Selection Based on Merit: Pakistan must recognize the importance of selecting specialists for key roles rather than making ad-hoc decisions. The absence of genuine wicket-taking spinners in the Champions Trophy squad was a glaring oversight that must not be repeated.

Strong Domestic Structure: A robust domestic cricket system is essential for producing match-winning players. Currently, Pakistan’s domestic setup lacks the structure and competitiveness needed to groom world-class talent. A reformed system, led by cricketing minds rather than political appointees, is crucial for long-term success.

Better Team Management and Coaching: Pakistan’s coaching staff must comprise individuals with proven track records and the ability to instill mental toughness in players. The PCB must consider hiring a sports psychologist to help players cope with high-pressure situations and develop a winning mindset.

Adapting to Modern Cricket: In today’s fast-paced cricketing world, teams that play with aggression and tactical awareness dominate. Pakistan must abandon outdated approaches and adopt a fearless, strategic style of play that aligns with contemporary ODI cricket.

PCB’s Accountability: Only an elected PCB, free from external influences, can ensure transparency and long-term planning. Frequent changes in PCB leadership, amendments for personal gains, and administrative instability have significantly contributed to Pakistan cricket’s struggles. This cycle must end.

Looking Ahead: Learning from
Mistakes

Pakistan’s early exit from the Champions Trophy is undoubtedly a setback, but it is not the end of the road. Cricket, like life, is about rebuilding after setbacks. Every great team goes through rough patches, and Pakistan must treat this as an opportunity to rethink and restructure.

Lessons must be learned. Planning must improve. Execution must be sharper. With the right changes, Pakistan cricket can reclaim its former glory. The nation’s passion for the game remains unwavering, and it is up to those at the helm to ensure that this passion translates into future success.

sarfraznews@hotmail.com