External debt share in public debt rises to 37pc by FY22

It was 36pc in FY20; it was still below the maximum limit of 40% by FY22

By Our Correspondent
|
Published July 04, 2023
A dealer counts US dollars at a currency exchange shop in Karachi. — AFP/File

ISLAMABAD: The share of external debt in total public debt increased slightly from 36 percent in 2019-20 to 37 percent in 2021-22 but remained below the benchmark (maximum limit) of 40 percent.

The increase was attributable mainly to exchange rate depreciation rather than excessive external borrowings. It was stated in Medium Term Debt Management Strategy for FY2023 to FY2026 released by the Ministry of Finance stated.

It states that the government has been able to meet most of the strategic benchmarks and targets during the last three years as envisaged in Medium Term Debt Management Strategy (2019/20 – 2022/23). However, a few targets set for 2021-22 with respect to debt risk indicators have not been met. Recent years have been challenging for the government due to the economic and fiscal impact of the catastrophic floods, the Covid-19 pandemic, volatility in international commodity prices, and global inflationary pressure.

These macroeconomic shocks resulted in increased borrowing requirements for the government. The performance of various indicators along with underlying reasons and future strategy to meet the benchmarks.

In relation to the currency risk, the maximum benchmark of external debt in total public debt is set to be 40 percent. In recent years, the increase in this ratio was attributable mainly to exchange rate depreciation rather than excessive external borrowings. Over the medium term, the government will aim to reduce the share of external debt in total public debt.

Refinancing risk: On the targets related to the refinancing risk, reason behind setting lower benchmark and target for ATM of domestic debt is that for external market for long-term loans exists – various multilateral financial institutions provide loans ranging from 20 to 40 years to developing countries at concessional rates, whereas, a domestic market for similar loans does not exist.

Until the domestic market grows and deepens to a level where loans for very long tenors are available, it is only reasonable and realistic to set relatively lower targets for ATM of domestic debt. One of the notable developments from debt management perspective in FY 2018-19 was the re-profiling of domestic debt, where government re-profiled the existing stock of SBP borrowing from short term (6 months) to medium to long term (1 to 10 years).

The re-profiling took into effect in the month of June 2019 and helped the government in reducing the rollover/refinancing risk of its domestic debt portfolio. However, as the SBP debt portfolio is running off and getting closer its major maturity in 2029, its weightage impact on the overall domestic ATM is increasing. Henceforth, the minimum benchmark for domestic debt ATM is 3.0 years and for external debt ATM is 6.0 years. Government aims to improve these indicators over the medium term in-line with the targets set under the MTDS. Furthermore, higher financing requirements primarily due to higher fiscal deficits at times require higher short-term borrowings. However, government is committed to ensure fiscal discipline and has set a GFN to GDP maximum benchmark of 35 percent.

Over the medium-term, the government objective is to reduce its GFN as well as GFN to GDP ratio through various measures mainly including (i) better cash flow management; (ii) higher issuance of long-term debt; (iii) development of regular Islamic based lending programmes; and (iv) availing maximum concessional financing from bilateral and multilateral development partners.

Diversification of lenders and borrowing instruments is important to reduce concentration risk. Diversification protects the borrower from over-reliance on any one category of lenders or borrowing instruments. Such over-reliance may exacerbate liquidity problems and worsen the borrowing costs in difficult times. Increasing the share of Sharia-compliant government securities is an important part of the diversification strategy. The rationale for this strategy is even stronger in the wake of high growth and rising market share of Sharia-compliant financial institutions in the country.

In light of this, government aims to increase the share of Sharia-compliant instruments in government securities to 15 percent till June 2026, while ensuring adherence to the yearly targets.

Interest Rate Risk: It is important to manage and maintain a high share of fixed-rate debt within domestic as well as external debt. Fixed-rate debt protects the borrower from unexpected increases in borrowing rates and other adverse economic developments. Under this MTDS, government has set a benchmark (minimum limit) of 20 percent for the share of fixed-rate debt within the domestic government securities.

No such benchmark or target has been set for external debt because the share of fixed-rate debt with external debt is already high. The reason behind setting conservative benchmark and target for fixed-rate debt within domestic government securities is that despite the increase in demand for fixed-rate securities, the government is shying away from fixed rate instruments to minimize its borrowing costs in the high interest rate environment, the typical case of adverse selection.

Domestic financial markets are dominated by commercial banks which have preference for floating-rate debt because their liabilities are mostly based on floating-rates. Further, the lack of price stability in the past has led to a lowering of investor demand for long-term fixed-rate government securities. Until the market share of investors (such as insurance companies and pension funds etc.) with a clear preference for long-term fixed-rate instruments is sufficiently met, and the government’s performance in the area of price stability improves substantially, it is appropriate to set targets for this indicator.

Share this story: